Do I think American Idol contestants should ever be allowed to sing The Beatles? Well thats laughable. But somehow they got the ok and now its fair game. Tread carefully contestants. If you choose to do this, it will most likely make or break your career. And I think that Lily Scott's version of "Fixing a Hole" did just that. Made her career. Bravo.
(Plus she sang "Fixing a Hole" on Idol, how cool is that!)